Sonic Drift: No seriously, I cannot see what the heck I'm even doing. The graphics are just plain horrible. I think the fact that my first exposure to this was on SADX stretched to widescreen may have affected this, but I've never liked driving games, and this is only worse. 2 is slightly better only because it's easier to see.
The Incredibles: Probably made worse by the fact that it was running on a computer that couldn't handle it, but the gameplay was really REALLY repetitive. Pick up enemy, throw at another enemy, rinse, repeat. The Incrediball level was its primary redeeming factor. Unfortunately, there's still the minor chance that I'll play it again, if not just to see if a better PC fixes it.
Left Behind Eternal Forces: OK, mildly controversial at its release due to its subject matter, and the fact that, "Oh look, they're Christians with guns!" Of course, none of the controversy mentioned the fact that the gameplay was just plain BAD in the first place. I mean really, you couldn't see a THING in that game. Plus, get this: even though there are roughly equal numbers of men and women in the city, women were restricted to health or morale professions - all construction, research, military, education, etc. fields were reserved for the men. WTH is even the point of that?!?!
Wii Play: One, it's not a game. Two, we already had a second controller. Three, the third controller isn't used much more often than when we have a visitor.